No, I’m not being sarcastic.
I watched, with jaw open and right eye squinting, the 2008 Tour of Gymnastics Superstars on television last night and couldn’t quite wrap my head around it.
Let’s start with the pros:
1. Blaine Wilson. What can I say? He was cool when I was a kid. And watching him pull high bar stunts in nothing but a pair of black jeans was…nice. Also, he has a tattoo of The Tick on his ankle. How can you not love him?
2. Exemplary elite gymnasts performing difficult elements on almost all events. (Maybe this should have been number one.)
3. Promoting the sport of gymnastics and breaking the mold of its usually strict and clean cut persona, making it appealing and accessible to a younger audience. Additionally, allowing younger audience members (undoubtedly for a pretty penny) to be on the floor and mere feet away from the performances.
4. Watching Olympians and national competitors having fun. It’s not often, unless they’ve won a medal, that you see so many smiles and silliness from gymnasts (unless you know one personally, in which case, good for you). Plus, everyone knows (girls, are you with me?) no matter what sport, performing with your hair down is just extra fun and exciting.
5. Shannon Miller’s cameo. Rock it 1/7th of the Magnificent Seven.
6. Rings to music: not a bad idea. Also, aerial rings, or whatever you call it–soaring through the air while performing on rings– very snazzy.
The cons:
1. Disney rock music during all events save one of Nastia Liukin’s floor routines which was jarringly and somewhat unsettlingly to “Ave Maria.” If it was a tribute, forgive me, but otherwise–that was so out there it was pythonesque.
2. The most ridiculous tween-targeting punk rock outfits and weird two-piece ensembles on the performers. Case in point: some girl on the uneven parallel bars in jeans and a t-shirt, and Nastia Liukin in a Jasmin from Aladdin type two piece on beam…to music.
3. Choreographing the gymnasts to encourage crowd participation with forced-looking hip hop dancing, random clapping and walking to the apparatus by way of the stadium stairs through the crowd.
4. Clips of the gymnasts lip syncing to Britney Spears backstage.
I have to say, watching Paul and Morgan Hamm flash gansta peace signs after pommel horse was one of those moments I’ll remember forever–whether I want to or not. While this tour is an outstanding way to promote the most challenging sport in the world (they did a study–back off football players), and also make it more appealing to the younger generation, it still scared the bajeebies out of me to see just how commercialized and affected the show had to be in order to be successful.
Yes, gymnastics is a performance sport and yes these are young, vibrant athletes who want to relate to people their own age, but in doing this, I feel like some dignity was traded in for success. My inner gymnastics granny is coming out here, but there is already drama in the sport: I mean this in the positive sense of drama. There is suspense, expectation, exultation and defeat. Does a pink sparkly, fringy, two piece really add anything?
Despite all this, if Shannon Miller and Blaine Wilson can embrace it, why can’t I? So, for pure love of the sport and in the spirit that any publicity is good publicity, I will.
In many ways, it reminded me of a tricked-out high school pep assembly. If money, location, time and talent were no object, this is exactly the type of pep assembly I would have died for back in the day. You could shake your tail feather on beam, throw a few of your best tricks, have amazing lighting, live music, an enthusiastic crowd and multiple costume changes (side note: did I mention none of the male gymnasts were allowed shirts?) without argument or explanation.
The old, overused and obvious adage here is, “sex sells.” Even to tweens. It was still great gymnastics, good entertainment, and…memorable to say the least.